Posted on - Jul 18, 2017

By Victor Ing

Victor Ing

Canada has experienced ongoing labour shortages for many years causing more employers to hire foreign workers to meet their business needs. The growth of Canada’s foreign worker program has led to the introduction, in recent years, of strict compliance measures for employers in all aspects of Canada’s immigration delivery system with Service Canada, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) and the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA). Failure to comply with the terms and conditions of the work permit application process can lead to serious consequences for employers.

The application process for employers seeking to hire foreign workers can only be described as onerous. The general process for an employer to bring a foreign worker to Canada is by obtaining a Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA) from Service Canada. A few years ago, this process only required an employer to complete a five-page application form without an application fee. Today there is a $1000 employer application fee (for each foreign worker) and two separate application forms – the 11-page LMIA application form and the 10-page Transition Plan. An employer must declare that they will comply with 18 individual obligations regarding the job offer to the foreign worker. Failure to comply with any of these 18 specific terms or conditions can result in an employer being non-compliant and bring about serious penalties.

In addition to the 18 specific obligations that an employer must commit to in the LMIA application form, there is a general declaration which must be agreed to directly above the signature of the employer with the following condition:

“I commit to hire the worker(s) covered by this application on a full-time basis as per the terms of the job offer described in this application and in the LMIA letter and annex upon issuance of the work permit and/or permanent resident visa(s).”

An employer must commit to honouring all of the terms and conditions of the job offer set out in the advertisements, job offer letter and LMIA documentation. The consequences for failing to comply with all of the specific provisions of the job offer can result in the loss of all foreign workers, having the company publicly blacklisted for a period of 2 years, being prohibited from applying for foreign workers for 2 years, up to a $50,000 fine and up to 2 years in jail. Yes, failure to do what you say you are going to do can result in jail time for an employer.

Your company can become the subject of a compliance audit based upon a history of previous non-compliance, being randomly selected or based upon a reason to suspect non-compliance such as a complaint from a member of the public or any federal, provincial or territorial government agency. Obviously, an unhappy worker who is not being employed in accordance with the terms of their job offer is a prime candidate to make a complaint against their employer. If you are selected for a compliance audit, it is your responsibility to demonstrate that your company has been compliant for ALL foreign workers and must be able to provide all relevant documentation for the previous six years.

What if you discover that you have breached a term or condition? How can you self correct? Service Canada, IRCC and CBSA will take into consideration the circumstances which led to non-compliance as well as the efforts made by an employer to self correct the breach of a term or condition. If there has been a change made to the terms of employment by an HR Manager, and you, as the company owner learn of this, then remedying the breach – such as back payment of wages – will go a long way in leading to a favourable outcome. But even where an employer may voluntarily remedy a breach of a term or condition of employment, if this comes to the attention of government officials, you can expect to be audited more frequently.

The shortage of workers for many businesses has driven employers to turn to Canada’s foreign worker program. Employing foreign workers may be essential to your company’s business objectives but the process has significant responsibilities for employers. Be sure that you and your senior management and human resources team are all completely familiar with all aspects of the LMIA and work permit application process. And be sure to “do what you say that you are going to do” for all of your foreign workers!


Victor Ing is a Vancouver immigration lawyer at Sas & Ing Immigration Law Centre in Vancouver, BC Canada, and provides a full range of immigration services.

To learn more about immigrating to Canada, becoming a permanent Canadian resident or bringing your family to Canada, email Victor Ing or call him at 1-604-689-5444.

Share this article:

Related Topics: , ,

Related Posts

Immigration Repeals Flawed Four-In, Four-Out Rule On December 13, 2016 the Department of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) repealed the “four-in, four-out” rule originally introduced in April 2011 that applied to certain temporary foreign workers to prevent them from working in Canada f...
Immigration Minister Alexander Tables Annual Report: Economic Immigration Levels Continue to Rise Last week Canada's Minister of Citizenship and Immigration Chris Alexander tabled his Annual Report to Parliament presenting an immigration action plan that will continue to maintain an overall high level of immigration with an increased focus on economic...
I have a criminal record – Can I come to Canada? Many travellers to Canada find themselves turned away at the border when a CBSA officer finds they have a criminal record.  In the post 9/11 world of continuously enhanced border security, CBSA officers are able to access an individual's criminal history ...
Does Canada Need More Temporary Foreign Workers? As long as there are immigration programs in Canada there will always be debate about whether we should be encouraging more or less immigration to this country. How many immigrants should we admit every year and in what program categories? What is the r...
Canada’s Immigration Playing Field is About to Change: Apply Now if You Can! The new Express Entry program is going to completely transform Canada’s Immigration Program. Historically Canada's economic immigration program was an applicant driven responsive program. Individuals who decided that they wanted to immigrate to Canada, su...
The Comprehensive Ranking Score – How do Students fare? In the new Express Entry immigration program, you are subject to an upfront pre-assessment of your qualifications : the Comprehensive Ranking Score (CRS). How many CRS points you score determines whether you are likely to receive an Invitation to Apply ...